A Genre By Any Other Name ~ Outside the Margins with Andrew Q Gordon

Join Prism Book Alliance® as Andrew Q Gordon goes Outside the Margins today.

What qualifies as Science Fiction? Does it require space ships and outer space? Is it an alternative version of earth where somethings are different, but the culture is otherwise the same? What about something set in the future? If the story is written in the past and the future has caught up to it, does that change the genre?

These might seem like silly questions, but lately I’ve been thinking about George Orwell’s 1984. I suspect I’m not alone because 1984 is #4 on the Kindle bestseller list as I write this. It’s #1 in Science Fiction, #1 in Literature and Fiction, and #1 in Classics.  Clearly a lot of people are buying this book (or downloading it from Kindle Prime.)

I read the book a few years before 1984, so to me it was still set ‘in the future,’ but I never considered it Science Fiction. To me it was more a political book that made a statement than Science Fiction. The science never seemed very sciency. To someone reading it now, would they consider it Sci-Fi? I doubt it.

Compare that to 2001, A Space Odyssey. What I didn’t know until I started to research this post was that this ‘novel’ was based on the screen play Arthur C. Clarke wrote with Stanley Kubrik for the 1968 movie. It was, however, based on Clarke’s 1948 short story The Sentinel. Little bit of trivia, the short story was written for a competition and it failed to place. It wasn’t published until 1951 under the title, Sentinel of Eternity. I would love to know what stories beat this out as I’m certain none are as famous as this.

The year 2001 has clearly come and gone and manned space travel hasn’t made it to Saturn or Jupiter. So like 1984, it was set in the future when written, but to those who read it now, it’s set in the past. But 2001 has always been and always will be Sci-Fi. It, along with Star Trek and some other movies and TV shows, laid the ground work for the genre.

What about X-men, Iron Man, Batman, or Superman? Are they Sci-Fi? Paranormal? Urban Fantasy? They all have technology well beyond what we can create today, but they’re mostly known for their spandex and muscles. Does the fact they came from a comic book and the characters are called superheroes make them something other than Science Fiction?

How about something like Mork and Mindy? Dude from outer space comes to current day earth? Or I am Number Four, by Pittacus Lore? Lots of dudes from outer space come to current day earth.  Sci-Fi or Not?

The notion of what something is called might seem insignificant, but it matters in the digital age. Readers search for books using search engines that troll the internet for information. Will the book show up if it’s listed as paranormal and someone searches for urban fantasy? I don’t know, but if your livelihood depended on selling books, it would be a huge question to answer.

But even before key words and search engine optimization, before target audiences were all the rage in fashioning on-line ads, there were card catalogs and library stacks divided by genre. I doubt Margret Mitchell would have been happy to have had Gone With The Wind sandwiched between Tolkien’s The Lord of The Rings and Asimov’s Foundation.

This is especially true today. Romance is (and likely will always be) the champion. It outsells all other genres. But Sci-Fi/Fantasy does pretty well too, so labeling it correctly does matter. I’d bet not many browsers in the molecular biology section would have been interested in George R. R. Martin’s A Game of Thrones.

As you can see, I’m not going to suggest the answer. So burn up Brandilyn’s comment section with your thoughts.

~Andrew Q Gordon

About Andrew Q Gordon

AQGLogo Full Size Enjoy The Journey![/caption]

Andrew Q. Gordon wrote his first story back when yellow legal pads, ball point pens were common and a Smith Corona correctable typewriter was considered high tech. Adapting with technology, he now takes his MacBook somewhere quiet when he wants to write.

He currently lives in the Washington, D.C. area with his partner of twenty years, their young daughter and dog. In addition to dodging some very self-important D.C. ‘insiders’, Andrew uses his commute to catch up on his reading. When not working or writing, he enjoys soccer, high fantasy, baseball and seeing how much coffee he can drink in a day.

Follow Andrew:

On his website: www.andrewqgordon.com,

On Facebook: www.facebook.com/andrewqugordon,

On Twitter: @andrewqgordon,

Or just email him: andrewqgordon@gmail.com


From Wayward Ink Publishing:
A Closed Door

From DSP Publications:
The Last Grand Master: (Champion of the Gods – Book 1)
The Eye and the Arm: (Champion of the Gods – Book 2) 
From Dreamspinner Press:

Self published:
Ashes of Life

Farewell Giveaway
I have a number of paperbacks, most of which are signed, to giveaway. Over the between now (11 Mar 2017) and 31 Mar 2017, every comment on the blog (this post and all other new posts), will be entered to win 1 of these paperbacks. There are also some misc swag items, so there will be a few packs of these to give away as well.

Thank you so much for your support over the last 4 years. Prism will be closing its doors on 1 April 2017. All content will remain available, but no new content will appear after 31 Mar 2017. As such all request forms have been turned off. Again Thank you,

This post may contain affiliate links.
Prism Book Alliance® assumes no liability for the ownership of photos or content used in guest posts and interviews.  The post author assumes all responsibility and liability for this content.

8 thoughts on “A Genre By Any Other Name ~ Outside the Margins with Andrew Q Gordon

  1. I’ve been thinking about 1984 a lot lately too. What a strange coincidence … 😏

    I never would have thought to classify it as science fiction, though. But I suppose anything that’s futuristic (at the time it is written) can fall into that genre. Most dystopias do have science fiction elements, so I suppose there’s a tendency to classify all of them as science fiction.

    But I am apparently terrible classifying things. Half the time, I could never figure out which is genres my own work resides in. As an author, I really need to figure that out—or create my own unique genre in which I become the number one bestseller for all time.

  2. 1984 is, without a doubt, science fiction. SF isn’t about tech we don’t have and space exploration. It’s about what might be. About what is possible – things to come. Regardless of the year we’re currently enduring, when Orwell wrote it, he was speculating about a possible future. A terrible one. A future of which we may be staring down the maw as I type. But for him a Possible Future.

    Sometimes this is called anthropological science fiction or even poli-sci science fiction – but like The Handmaid’s Tale, like Brave New World, like Last Babylon, Orwell took events he saw in his present and extrapolated them into the future. This. Is. Science. Fiction. And something, you might be able to tell, that I feel strongly about. It’s not all Golden Age spaceships and aliens. SF is about looking ahead at what might, perhaps, someday happen.

Leave a Reply